Amongst all the hype about the population boom and the popularity of the “zero population growth” movement, some of the more wealthy countries in the world are facing a very different problem:
http://www.vancouversun.com/Technology/Lack%20babies%20threatens%20life/1773454/story.html
The question posed at the end of the article is interesting to me – how to get “young liberal Westerners” to choose parenthood.
I don’t really know the answer to that. I’m not particularly “liberal” which might have something to do with the fact that I’ve always wanted to have a fairly large family. However, I’m young and I’m an American and I’ve also personally been bucking the current trend of waiting until the late-20s or early-30s to have children since I was 21 years old. So I thought that maybe I should take a stab at why I feel so differently about this issue than my contemporaries seem to feel. Why was I so willing to embrace motherhood? I was married at age 20 and I got pregnant (and was more than happy to be pregnant) for the first time only a month after turning 21.
It’s a difficult, maybe even impossible, thing to quantify… I’ve always looked at future jobs/careers in the light of what I could easily manage while staying at home with my passel of kids. That’s one reason I love teaching private music lessons. It’s a good amount of money for the time spent and it can easily be scheduled either around my husband’s work or I can occupy my children with other things while I’m busy teaching. Private music lessons can also be taught at my home or at the home of my students – something I only offer if my children are welcome in the other family’s home which hasn’t been a problem so far since most families who choose lessons at their home have large families themselves. Those have all been important career considerations to me ever since I can remember.
My mom was a stay-at-home-mom and still is for my much younger siblings who are still living at home. My dad has always valued and appreciated her contribution to the family so I grew up thinking that staying at home and raising children has value. My husband agrees with me about that – his mother was also around a lot when he was young. Growing up in a church where larger families (ranging from 4-12 children in a family) were common probably didn’t hurt any either. Large families were not required or even expected in my church and it wasn’t a church that taught that birth control was evil or anything, but most families in the church viewed children as blessings and not as hardships.
Fueling the “children as a hardship” idea are the inevitable expenses of having children. I don’t deny that having children can cost a lot of money, but I’ve personally never bought into the “more is better” or even “new is better” aspects of consumerism… I’d much rather buy needed things at Salvation Army, yardsales, or Goodwill than the mall or Wal-Mart. Not feeling the need to buy many things or new things unless absolutely necessary has really cut back the cost of having children for my family! I’m optimistic that I can continue this way of life even as my children get older because of the success that others like Amy Dacyczyn have had in passing along their frugal values to their children – even their teen children. This remains to be seen in my case, of course, but I don’ t think my children will have much of a choice in the matter regardless
Then there are the pregnancy and birth climates in the Western world! Who really wants to go through multiple c-sections when the risks increase so much with every single one? The first one isn’t so bad, but once you’ve had even 1 prior c-section, your risks in subsequent pregnancies and births go up quite a lot. Who even wants to go through multiple vaginal births with the, sometimes overpowering, fear surrounding childbirth in our society? I was very fortunate to learn about natural/home birth and to personally know so many women who were not afraid of birth (and were very open about their positive – or at least not horrible – experiences) and who gave birth at home, but most women aren’t so lucky.
Most women in our culture are literally inundated with birth horror stories from the time other women find out about their pregnancy. Unfortunately, with managed birth and lack of evidence-based care being the norm in American hospitals, women are also likely to find their birth experience to be rather more unpleasant than necessary which serves to fulfill the horror stories they heard during pregnancy. Instead of being a time for rejoicing because a child is about to be born, birth is a time for dreading what comes next.
Pregnancy in our culture has likewise moved from being a time of joy and anticipation to being a time of fear and trepidation. All the tests that are done on the unborn child and the resulting anxiety for the mother if everything doesn’t come back exactly perfect don’t exactly encourage women to go through the ordeal of pregnancy more times than is absolutely necessary.
I am so grateful to all the women who shared their positive pregnancy and birth stories with me as well as their horror stories about misdiagnosed issues with their babies that caused them more worry than was necessary. I think that their encouragement was a large part of why I was able to avoid the fear of pregnancy and childbirth that seems to be so ingrained in our society today. Yes, things can go terribly wrong, but it doesn’t happen nearly as often as shows on TLC would have women believe.
I definitely believe that pressure to have careers, feeling the need to do it all before having children, and the news stories about overpopulation have a lot to do with why so many women wait to have children or have fewer children than they might have wanted, but the issues above are the ones that most influenced me in wanting children. I know the issue is a complicated one without a simple answer – it just got me to thinking about why things are this way and why I’m apparently different.
I’m not sure how to change things to be more family-friendly in our culture, but I truly believe that support for young couples/mothers who want or who had children earlier than our culture deems “appropriate” and positive support for pregnant women of all ages would go a long way towards encouraging a higher birthrate. Paid maternity leave wouldn’t hurt either…
~B.
Birth
October 18, 2009 by barefootbetsy
So, I’m 35 weeks pregnant today and it’s that time again: Time to start thinking seriously about birth! It’s a little difficult for me to really focus on birth currently because of everything else going on. I’ve thought about it a little – after all, we’re about to move partly because I cannot imagine giving birth in the house we’re in right now – but not as much as I think I should have.
So, why now? Why in the middle of packing and finding crazy ant nests moving from the heating ducts to under a chair in the living room am I suddenly thinking about birth? Well, partly because I’m 35 weeks along, but also partly because I went to a baby shower yesterday and even though the mother is having twins and therefore a c-section, the topic of birth did come up.
It’s always interesting talking to my dad’s family about the choices that my family has made – breastfeeding, home birth, elimination communication, co-sleeping etc. – because they just don’t understand why anyone would make those choices. The choices I’ve made seem difficult to them and I’m pretty sure that they see at least a few of them as just another way I’m tied down to my children. The funny thing about that is that I view my choices as the easiest and best choices I could possibly have made. I cannot imagine having to sterilize bottles or get up in the middle of the night because my child is crying in another room. I cannot imagine having to let my baby cry for a few minutes because I have to mix up formula when it’s so much easier and quicker to just hike my shirt up and let them eat.
If I’m being completely honest with myself, I don’t do these things because science backs me up at all. Really, I do these things mainly because I’m lazy. One of the main reasons I started looking into home birth wasn’t because of some “birth experience” or because it’s safer for low-risk women or because I’m some crazy hippie person, but because riding in a car during labor (and possibly giving birth in the car!) just did not appeal to me at all. Why go somewhere else to have the baby when you can simply stay right at home?
The proven safety of home birth was merely a side perk that helped me to justify my choice to other people. The amazing experience of home birth was a very cool perk that just happened to exist, but wasn’t my main reason. After all, I’ve never had a hospital birth so I truly have nothing to compare home birth to.
Anyhow, back to my dad’s family and the interesting things they have to say about my choices. Yesterday my dad’s mom (my Grandma) mentioned that she loved her hospital births. She went to the hospital, they knocked her out, and when she woke up they gave her the baby. A couple of older family members who’d had similar births agreed with her and I smiled and nodded, not wanting to open my mouth lest too much come out. It’s not as if they’ll be having any more babies, they’re happy with their births, and it’s not as if they’ll be making me change my mind or as if I’m defensive about my choice.
However, the truth is that the very thought of having a baby and not being able to remember it terrifies me. My first thought after contemplating what they said was: How did they know that they got their baby back? I know that nowadays they have all sorts of fancy equipment to prevent babies from going to the wrong parents, but back then… if all the mothers were knocked out (which, most were) and if all the babies were taken to the nursery (which, they were) then how did anyone know that they got their baby? It’s not as if they saw the baby before it was whisked away to be washed and examined and the fathers weren’t allowed in the room either. It’s a very scary thought to me.
I don’t know. They’re obviously happy and they had healthy babies and that’s really what matters, but it’s odd to me that they can say so confidently that their unknown births were so much better than fully experienced births when they’ve never experienced birth. Neither can I honestly say that mine were better than theirs, but I can genuinely say that my births were amazing events that I am blessed to have been able to remember!
The amazing event isn’t the most important thing about birth – the most important thing about birth is that the mother and baby are happy and healthy – but the memory of my births is important. At least to me. Whether in the future I have a home birth, a managed hospital birth, or a c-section, I wouldn’t want to be put completely under and I would want to remember the moment my baby was first held up for me to see even if I couldn’t feel anything from the waist down. I would want as much of the experience as I could have even if I couldn’t have the full experience at home. I would, at the very least, want to remember what my baby looked like right after he or she was born. Before a bath. Before an exam. Before the cord was cut.
Birth is amazing and newborns are amazing! I’m so glad that I live in a time when I wasn’t forced to blank out the entire experience or motivated by fear to seek out obliteration of my own volition. I’m so glad that I live in a time when other, more experienced, mothers could encourage me to look more into birth and what it means before I had my first baby. I used to wish I had been born a few decades before the 80s, but no longer. I was born in the correct time and place and I am so thankful for that. I’m also infinitely grateful to my friends and family members who stuck by me and encouraged me to make different choices than most of them did.
So now, it’s time to begin thinking about my next birth. A birth that will happen in two to seven weeks from today. The day that I will meet the stranger who’s currently living in my womb and poking me almost constantly with feet, knees, hands, and elbows. Who is this person? I can’t wait to find out! What will the journey be like? I’m looking forward to experiencing it! It will be difficult but I can do it – I’ve done it before. It might be long and will almost certainly be intense but there’s always an end – it will end with a brand new human being to love.
So soon. Very soon! It won’t be long now.
~B.
Posted in Childbirth, Homebirth, Life, Pregnancy | Tagged birth, Childbirth, health, interesting comments, Life, myself, Pregnancy, rambling, reflection, relatives, support, thoughts | 1 Comment »